Renderings of four competing designs for the First & Broadway Civic Park in Downtown Los Angeles were presented at a public meeting earlier this week.

The four teams competing were led by AECOM, Brooks + Scarpa, Eric Owen Moss, and Mia Lehrer + Associates, with several other firms supporting each lead.

The proposed two-acre green space will comprise a full city block of the Civic Center, bounded by 1st Street, Broadway, Spring Street and Grand Park.  The currently vacant lot is located almost directly across the street from Los Angeles City Hall.

AECOM

AECOM’s proposal was designed by their DTLA Landscape Architecture and Urban Design Studio.  It features a large lawn in the center of the park surrounded by six groves of trees.  It is flanked on the north corner by the Paper Plane — a restaurant covered by a green roof and trellis.  It is mirrored in the south corner by the Wingnut— a structure created by the ground sloping up to a green roof. The Wingnut would contain a park outfitter and a gallery.

plan

model
AECOM_FAB_V01_FINAL

AECOM_FAB_V02_FINAL

AECOM_FAB_V03_FINAL

AECOM_FAB_V04_FINAL

 

Brooks + Scarpa Architects

Brooks + Scarpa’s design features undulating grassy ribbons in the north half of the park.  The ribbons rise to form the green roof of an event center.  The south half of the park mirrors the turf covered ribbons of the north half with ribbons of hardscape, interspersed with shade trees.  Renderings also show a public art piece in the south corner.

 

12496103_902616093120990_6940710983024178427_o

brooks_scarpa_civic_park_1

12593655_902911303091469_3396114745292915808_o

VIEW 1-1903x1122_0

VIEW 2-1903x1122_0

brooks_scarpa_composite_diagrams brooks_scarpa_plan_view

Eric Owen Moss Architects

Eric Owen Moss Architects’ design emphasizes both ground level and subterranean space, and features an underground restaurant covered by a green roof which serves as both an event lawn and a covered gallery.  The proposal also features a multilevel public event pavilion constructed with an open steel frame wrapped in a translucent material.  This material allows the pavilion to double as a projection surface that could be used for public art or outdoor film screenings.  Filling out the site are two amphitheaters, exhibition areas and a hide-and-seek forest.
eom_civic_park_1

eom_civic_park_2

eom_civic_park_4

eom_civic_park_5

Mia Lehrer + Associates

The last proposal comes from Mia Lehrer + Associates, and features a mostly hardscape central area surrounded by gardens and wooded areas.  A green-roofed structure in the north corner contains several restaurants and a beer garden.  A wooden, terraced area in the south corner contains a meadow and wash.  Throughout the site, clusters of tulip-like canopies provide shade.  The design emphasizes connections to surrounding streets, with connecting areas labeled the “Spring Steps”, “Broadway Walk”, and “First Broadway Gateway”.

mla_civic_1

mla_civic_2

mla_civic_3

mla_civic_4

Efforts to create the park are being led by the City of Los Angeles’s Bureau of Engineering (BoE).  According to a presentation on the BoE’s website, park proposals should incorporate themes of climate change, water scarcity, a multicultural Los Angeles, civic engagement, geology and seismic activity.  Competing entrants are also directed to demonstrate “advanced digital design and construction techniques”.

Boards and models for the four finalists’ proposals are currently on view at the Department of Building and Safety at 201 North Figueroa.

The multiyear effort to create the park began in 2013 under former Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa’s tenure when the city purchased the lot for $7.5 million.  Since then, funds from Quimby fees and the Department of Parks and Recreation have both been allocated towards the project.  The cost to build the new park has been estimated at $10 million.

For decades, the site contained an underground parking structure and foundation of a former state office building — as well as feral cat colony.  In the time since, the city has demolished the structures and relocated the cat colony.  Now the lot empty, waiting for its second act.